lichess.org
Donate

Multiple Correct Solutions to Puzzles Not Accepted?

On this puzzle http://en.lichess.org/training/25523 for my third move I played Rb8 and was told I failed the puzzle.

However Rb8 here is approximately -8.5 and has the point of the problem in mind which is to win the white bishop on c1.

The correct solution given is Qxc3 (which I intended to play on the next move) which is also approximately -8.5 and perhaps just a few centipawns superior a move.

I don't understand why sometimes the trainer tells me "good move but you can do better" but on so many problems only accepts one solution when more are available.

I know that often problems are set such that I could play a move that is +5 in my favor but if I'm missing a mate in 3 then I get puzzle failed. I could quibble with that but I at least like that it teaches me to always look for something better.

But sometimes, such as with this puzzle, I just don't understand the difference between moves accepted as winning and moves given as failing.
I'm wondering now if it has anything to do with the computer needing to follow a forced line in the puzzle trainer in order to continue the problem.

For instance when I play 3. Rb8 the computer could play several pawn moves that are all similarly losing to handle their bank rank issue while 3. Qxc3 indicates one clear reply.

This topic has been archived and can no longer be replied to.